Cobalt Open Sales System BHP Billiton

Auditors' Report

<Back    You are here: Home / Auditors' Report
COSS Cobalt Price : $36.25    Sep 2008

AUDITORS' REPORT ON SCHEDULE OF COBALT SALES

To the Management of WMC Resources Marketing Limited

We have audited the schedule of cobalt sales of WMC Resources Marketing Limited ("WRML") for the period from January 1, 2005 to June 30, 2005 which has been compiled on the basis detailed in Note 1 to the schedule. This financial information is the responsibility of the management of WRML. Our responsibility is to express an opinion on this financial information based on our audit.

We conducted our audit in accordance with Canadian generally accepted auditing standards. Those standards require that we plan and perform an audit to obtain reasonable assurance whether the financial information is free of material misstatement. An audit includes examining, on a test basis, evidence supporting the amounts and disclosures in the financial information. An audit also includes assessing the accounting principles used and significant estimates made by management, as well as evaluating the overall financial information.

In our opinion, this schedule presents fairly, in all material respects, the cobalt sales of WRML for the period from January 1, 2005 to June 30, 2005 in accordance with the basis of presentation as detailed in Note 1 to the schedule.

PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP
Chartered Accountants
Toronto, Ontario
23 August 2005

SCHEDULE OF COBALT SALES
For the period from January 1, 2005 to June 30, 2005

Sale Date Quantity Delivery Date Price
(US$/lb)
Notes
28 Jun 2005 5 MT Aug 2005 $13.50 North America
28 Jun 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $13.50 Europe
22 Jun 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $13.30 North America
22 Jun 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $12.90 North America
22 Jun 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $12.90 North America
20 Jun 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $13.20 North America
14 Jun 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $13.80 Europe
13 Jun 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $13.90 Europe
13 Jun 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $13.90 Europe
7 Jun 2005 10 MT Jun 2005 $14.85 Asia
26 May 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $15.85 North America
19 May 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $16.20 North America
19 May 2005 10 MT Jul 2005 $15.80 North America
17 May 2005 5 MT Jul 2005 $16.20 North America
17 May 2005 10 MT Jun 2005 $15.60 North America
16 May 2005 10 MT May 2005 $15.30 Asia
13 May 2005 10 MT Jul 2005 $15.25 Europe
10 May 2005 10 MT May 2005 $15.25 Asia
9 May 2005 5 MT May 2005 $15.40 Europe
6 May 2005 5 MT Jun 2005 $15.75 Europe
29 Apr 2005 10 MT Jun 2005 $15.75 North America
27 Apr 2005 5 MT Jun 2005 $16.45 North America
20 Apr 2005 10 MT May 2005 $17.25 Europe
19 Apr 2005 10 MT Jun 2005 $16.95 Europe
18 Apr 2005 5 MT Apr 2005 $16.80 Europe
15 Apr 2005 5 MT Jun 2005 $16.80 Europe
5 Apr 2005 5 MT Apr 2005 $17.95 Europe
1 Apr 2005 Greater than 10 MT May 2005 $17.95 North America
24 Mar 2005 10 MT May 2005 $17.75 North America
23 Mar 2005 5 MT May 2005 $16.75 North America
23 Mar 2005 5 MT Apr 2005 $16.75 Europe
23 Mar 2005 10 MT Apr 2005 $15.75 Europe
22 Mar 2005 10 MT May 2005 $15.20 North America
18 Mar 2005 5 MT Apr 2005 $15.20 North America
16 Mar 2005 10 MT Mar 2005 $14.85 Asia
10 Mar 2005 5 MT Mar 2005 $15.35 Europe
10 Mar 2005 5 MT Mar 2005 $15.35 Europe
9 Mar 2005 5 MT Apr 2005 $15.35 North America
9 Mar 2005 5 MT Apr 2005 $15.35 North America
9 Mar 2005 5 MT Apr 2005 $15.35 North America
4 Mar 2005 5 MT Apr 2005 $16.00 North America
24 Feb 2005 5 MT Mar 2005 $17.15 Europe
22 Feb 2005 10 MT Feb 2005 $17.15 Europe
18 Feb 2005 5 MT Feb 2005 $17.80 Europe
16 Feb 2005 5 MT Feb 2005 $17.80 Europe
4 Feb 2005 5 MT Mar 2005 $19.25 North America
4 Feb 2005 5 MT Mar 2005 $19.25 North America
2 Feb 2005 5 MT Mar 2005 $19.25 North America
24 Jan 2005 5 MT Jan 2005 $19.25 Europe
24 Jan 2005 5 MT Feb 2005 $19.25 North America
17 Jan 2005 5 MT Jan 2005 $19.10 Europe
17 Jan 2005 5 MT Jan 2005 $19.10 Europe
4 Jan 2005 10 MT Feb 2005 $19.14 Europe
4 Jan 2005 10 MT Feb 2005 $19.14 Europe

Note 1. Basis of Presentation

The schedule of cobalt sales has been compiled to provide information on recent WRML transactions in cobalt as per WRML's specifications detailed on the Cobalt Web site, cobalt.bhpbilliton.com.

The schedule of cobalt sales to arm's length parties includes sales contracted during the period January 1, 2005 to June 30, 2005 and those sales contracted as of June 30, 2005 which will be delivered subsequent to that date.